So maybe you've never drawn from the
nude model before. Or maybe you've done it a hundred times. It's an
unusual situation that doesn't have precedent or parallel for most of
us outside the life drawing group. How are we supposed to act? I've
been going to life drawing sessions for years and no one has really
ever addressed this to me. The assumption is that you should know
already, but why would you?
The model is presenting themselves as a
subject of study. We're there to draw the model and to learn from the
process. But the model is also, nude, and being nude can be a
vulnerable position. Maybe the model is very comfortable with their
body. Maybe they're not so confident. Maybe they're sensitive about
their appearance. These are things we can't really know.
It's good to make the model feel
welcome. It's good to be gracious. It's good to talk to them like a
person, just as you would anyone else. It's good to give them some
space during the break, especially when they're in the process of
covering themselves. But it's not a good idea to talk about their
bodies. Even with the best intentions, this is a very iffy area. I've
done it myself. I've made, what I thought, were innocent comments
about the models appearance, but you can't know how those comments
are going to be interpreted. No matter how the comment is intended,
if it's about the models body, even if it's complimentary, even if
it's innocent, even if it doesn't seem to be inappropriate, it's
better to err on the side of just not going there. For example: “you
have pretty hair.” or “You have beautiful eyes.” No matter how
innocently intended, this is the kind of comment best to be avoided.
Even if you're not talking directly to
the model, even if the model isn't in the room, it's best not to talk
about how attractive they are. They're not there for your gaze, but
for your study. This is a very important distinction. We've all seen
beautiful pictures of beautiful people, and there's nothing wrong
with seeing them as beautiful, but in the life drawing session,
respecting the model and what they're there to do means leaving these
kinds of judgements and evaluations behind.
But if you have made comments like
these, its not necessarily a tragedy or disaster, but as a rule of
thumb, it's best to try to avoid making them in the future. We want
everyone's experience, including the model's, to be a positive one,
and it's up to all of us to do what we can to to make this a reality.
Thank you, Jed, for writing this. It helps for someone to point out how our comments about the models body whether positive or negative can be misinterpreted. It is a sensitive matter.
ReplyDeleteThanks! And it's not only a question of sexually inappropriate comments, but really anything about the model's appearance that draws attention to how you view their body, especially aesthetically. It's not always easy to avoid, especially when you're thinking about how much you admire their hair, or back as a drawing subject. It may be the kind of thing you would say to a casual acquaintance--"you really have great hair!" and in a casual social setting, that's an appropriate compliment. But the relationship with the model, when it comes to the display of their body, is a professional one.
ReplyDeleteBut I also really want to stress that the protocol isn't obvious. This is something George and I discussed at length and I think he really gave me a lot of insight on this. It's so seldom discussed because it can be an uncomfortable subject, but it's a subject worth discussing. I also put this essay on the "About" page of the Meetup site, since there's such a variety of folks that show up to the sessions, and you don't know what their background or experience is. The idea is not to chastise, but to inform.